Mince or steak? Z Energy weighs in on the national pie debate
November 16, 2026
Across Aotearoa New Zealand the humble pie has always been a hero when it comes to satisfying hunger.
Hot, hearty and filling, pies are part of our national identity. As to precisely which pie leads the pack, new data from Z Energy (Z) shows opinions are split along regional lines: Mince and Cheese leads in Wellington, Waikato, Bay of Plenty, Hawke’s Bay and Taranaki; Steak and Cheese comes out on top in Auckland, Christchurch and much of the South Island. Ultimately Steak and Cheese takes the crown as New Zealand’s favourite according to Z’s data.
Z’s Head of Retail, Aaron Brooker, says the results point to a close contest between the flavours. “Our retail stores are grouped into regional clusters across the country, so we can see which pies are preferred in each cluster from a customer point of view. It’s an exceptionally tight race in each region, but those two are winning by a long shot.”
Investing in a great food and beverage offer is important to Z. As customers’ needs and tastes evolve, Z is continuing to invest in quality, value and innovation across its convenience range, giving people more choice and making it easier to find something satisfying while they’re on the go.
Looking further down the list, the Gourmet Butter Chicken Pie typically ranks well, but recently Z’s limited-time Gourmet Beef Brisket Mac and Cheese Pie has been performing strongly in the popularity stakes too.
So what makes the pie our (unofficial) national dish? Aaron has a theory: “Many of us have grown up eating and enjoying pies, so there’s a real nostalgic value to them. That said, they have really evolved over the past decade. Today, there’s something for everyone from simple, familiar favourites to gourmet flavours and fillings. The level of innovation and the quality of the product itself has increased so much.”
Interestingly, Z’s data also shows that pies are enjoyed at just about any time of day. “We see customers buying pies from first thing in the morning right through to afternoon and evening,” says Aaron. “For breakfast they might pair it with one of our barista-made coffees. Later in the day, a classic Kiwi lunch might be a pie, a sandwich and a beverage from the chiller. Pies are quick, convenient and fulfilling in all the ways you need when you’re out on the road.”
The reason Z’s pies are so popular comes down to a combination of factors. “It starts with the pastry,” says Aaron. “Our pies are made with flaky, buttery pastry from our friends at The Goodtime Pie Co – and that high standard is a key point of difference. From there, we focus on good quality ingredients and offering our customers an innovative range.”
The wide selection of pies at Z means there’s something to suit a variety of tastes. The Classic range includes favourites such as the Classic Mince and Classic Creamy Chicken. The Gourmet range features options including the Gourmet Beef Nacho, Gourmet Bacon and Egg and Gourmet Vegan Pepper Shroom. Z also offers limited-time Ultimate Pies, including Aaron’s personal favourite, the Ultimate Beef Brisket, Smoked Cheddar and Jalapeño.
To celebrate the place pies hold in our collective hearts, Z recently ran a nationwide campaign, ‘Z is for the Love of Pies’. This campaign saw bus shelters in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch transformed to showcase pies in all their glory. All three sites presented pies as works of art, complete with gallery-style frames.
If you’re still deciding which pie is your favourite – or if you’ve never sampled a Z pie before – Aaron’s message is simple: “Come in and try one. You’ll be amazed at the quality, the value and the range.”
And don’t forget the golden rule: Always blow on the pie.